Specifics of legal thinking in Germany (1930–1940s): Carl Schmitt’s and Carl Larenz’s reflections on values
https://doi.org/10.28995/2073-6304-2025-3-207-224
Abstract
Under the influence of historical changes that took place in Germany during the period of national socialism and after the WW2, German legal scholars C. Schmitt and C. Larenz repeatedly returned to the topic of legal thinking: Schmitt – in such works on the theory of law and political theory as “Dictatorship” (1921), “Political Theology” (1922), “On Three Types of Legal Thinking” (1934), “Nomos of the Earth” (1950) and “Tyranny of Values” (1960). Larenz did his research on legal thinking in “Legal Entity and Subjective Law as a Turn to Basic Legal Concepts” (1935), “On the Logic of a Concrete Concept” (1940) and “Methodology of Jurisprudence” (1960), all of them being of narrower than Schmitt’s focus. In order to identify the method and type of legal thinking, Schmitt developed a doctrine of thinking in categories of a concrete order, Larenz – a study of concrete-universal concepts. Both intellectual constructs are characterized by a high degree of their adaptability to legal values, the idea of which was revealed by Schmitt and Larenz in the process of constitutionalization of the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany when constitutional rights were granted a value status.
The paper deals with the conceptual analysis of legal thinking in Germany of the 30–40s of the 20th century from the position of Carl Schmitt and Carl Larenz and the comparison of their ideas about legal values enshrined in the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany. The relevance of such an analysis is explained by (a) the lack of Russian research devoted to a comparative analysis of views shared by Schmitt and his contemporaries and (b) the lack of Larenz’s books translated into Russian. As for the works of foreign legal theorists on the stated theme, the most detailed comparative analysis undertaken by Schmitt and Larenz was carried out by Bernd Rüthers (1930–2023), a German legal scholar, whose works the author of the paper will repeatedly refer to.
About the Author
B. A. Antonov
Russian State University for the Humanities
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Boris A. Antonov, Cand. of Sci. (Law), associate professor
bld. 6, Miusskaya Square, Moscow, 125047
References
1. Antonov, B.A. (2023), “Legal Thinking from the Position of K. Schmitt and K. Larenz: on the Conceptual-Content Rethinking of the German Legal Order in the Third Reich”, Leningradskii yuridicheskii zhurnal – Leningrad Legal Journal, no. 4 (74), pp. 27-54.
2. Antonov, M. (2021), “Legal positivism and issues of the development of Russian law”, Ideology and Politics Journal, Russia, no. 2 (18), pp. 121-151.
3. Borulenkov, Yu.P. (2017), “Legal thinking as an intellectual component of legal knowledge”, Pravovedenie, no. 2 (331), pp. 6-41.
4. Filippov, A.F. (2000), “Carl Schmitt. Heyday and disaster”, Karl Shmitt. Politicheskaya teologiya [Carl Schmitt. Political Theology], Kanon-press-TS, Kuchkovo pole, Moscow, Russia.
5. Kil’dyushov, O.V. (2010), Chitaya Shmitta [While reading Carl Shmitt], Gosudarstvo i politicheskaya forma, State and political form. Trasnsl. from Germ. by O.V. Kild’yushov. Izd. dom Gos. universiteta, Moscow, Russia.
6. Кильдюшов 2010 – Кильдюшов О.В. Читая Шмитта // Государство и политическая форма / Пер. с нем. О.В. Кильдюшова. М: Изд. дом Гос. ун-та, 2010. 272 с.
7. Kil’dyushov, O.V. (2013), “Between law and politics, Сarl Schmitt at the beginning of 30s”, Gosudarstvo. Pravo i politika [State. Law and politics.], Territoriya budushchego, Moscow, Russia, pp. 7-27.
8. Кильдюшов О.В. Между правом и политикой: Карл Шмитт в начале 30-х // Государство. Право и политика. М.: Территория будущего, 2013. С. 7–27.
9. Kondurov, V.E. (2018), “The foundations of the validity of legal order and the problem of the justiciability of the ‘political’: С. Schmitt on the limits of justice”, Proceedings of the Institute of State and Law of the RAS, vol. 13, no 5, pp. 64-91.
10. Kondurov, V.E. (2023a), Carl Schmitt’s Political Theology: A Theoretical and Legal Study, PhD Thesis, Saint Petersburg, Russia.
11. Kondurov, V.E. (2023b), “Karl Schmitt’s ‘Tyranny of Values’ in the context of the debate on the nature of constitutional rights”, Russian Sociological Review, vol. 22, no 3, pp. 96-124.
12. Larenz, K. and Kanaris, K-V. (2024), Metodologiya yurisprudentsii [Methodology of jurisprudence], M-Logos, Moscow, Russia.
13. Mering, R. (2018), “’The state of European Jurisprudence’ by Carl Schmitt”, Russian Sociological Review, vol. 17, no 1, pp. 30-54.
14. Rüthers, B. (2020), “Philosophy of law in the ruins of the post-war period: Commentary on the report of Monica Frommel”, Justice, vol. 2, no 3, pp. 213-224.
15. Rüthers, B., Fischer, C. and Birk, A. (2018), Rechtstheorie mit Juristischer Methodenlehre, Lehrbuch/Studienliteratur, München, Germany.
16. Schmitt, K. (2011), Tiraniya cennostei [Tyranny of values], 3-d ed., Dunker und Humblot Ferlag, Berlin, Germany, pp. 1-22.
17. Schmitt, K. (2013), “About three types of legal thinking”, Gosudarstvo: pravo i politika [State. Law and Politics], Territoriya budushchego, Moscow, Russia, pp. 307-356.
18. Schmitt, K. (2016a), Ponyatie politicheskogo [The concept of the political], Nauka, Saint Petersburg, Russia.
19. Schmitt, K. (2016b), “Political theology”, Ponyatie politicheskogo [The concept of the political], Nauka, Saint Petersburg, Russia.
20. Stolleis, M. (2017), Istoriya publichnogo prava v Germanii: Veimarskaya respublika i natsional-sotsializm [The history of public law in Germany. The Weimar Republic and National Socialism], Politicheskaya entsiklopediya, Moscow, Russia.
21. Timoshina, E.V. (2023), “The ‘Tyranny of Values’ as the ‘WILL to Power’: on the genealogy and effects of value discourse in justice”, Russian Sociological Review, vol. 22, no 3, pp. 125-141.
Review
For citations:
Antonov B.A. Specifics of legal thinking in Germany (1930–1940s): Carl Schmitt’s and Carl Larenz’s reflections on values. RSUH/RGGU BULLETIN. Series Economics. Management. Law. 2025;(3):207-224. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.28995/2073-6304-2025-3-207-224
Views:
58
Email this article 